Arya has learned from her families mistakes. As well as her own. She will not suffer a betrayal twice.
Ironically this makes Arya like Tywin Lannister.
I think Arya is learning from those two. Keep the Honor of a Stark as needed but put down an Enemy ruthlessly when called for like Tywin. I mean the poisoning of House Fray was more Tywin than Ned. But refusing to kill the actress was all Ned.
Arya has learned from her families mistakes. As well as her own. She will not suffer a betrayal twice.
Ironically this makes Arya like Tywin Lannister.
I think Arya is learning from those two. Keep the Honor of a Stark as needed but put down an Enemy ruthlessly when called for like Tywin. I mean the poisoning of House Fray was more Tywin than Ned. But refusing to kill the actress was all Ned.
I know we here like irony. And you know how Dany has that prophecy of Three? 3 mounts/betrayals/fires? I think there.should totally be one for Arya. But it would be like 3 fathers/tragedies/masters. Like it would be super fucking dark.
I know we here like irony. And you know how Dany has that prophecy of Three? 3 mounts/betrayals/fires? I think there.should totally be one for Arya. But it would be like 3 fathers/tragedies/masters. Like it would be super fucking dark.
You have my vote. As long as the Hound gets one of the 3 father roles XD ..I've always been of the mind that he really helped shape her even more than Jaqen.
I know we here like irony. And you know how Dany has that prophecy of Three? 3 mounts/betrayals/fires? I think there.should totally be one for Arya. But it would be like 3 fathers/tragedies/masters. Like it would be super fucking dark.
You have my vote. As long as the Hound gets one of the 3 father roles XD ..I've always been of the mind that he really helped shape her even more than Jaqen.
Three Fathers you'll know. One for Honor (Ned), One for Cunning(Tywin), One For Blood(The Hound). Three Tragedies you'll witness. One for Honor(Ned), One for Power(Red Wedding), One for... something else. Three Masters you'll have. One for Water(Syro), One for.. something, and One for Death(Jaqen).
Three Fathers you'll know. One for Honor (Ned), One for Cunning(Tywin), One For Blood(The Hound).
Starky Approves. Though isn't it funny how well Tywin fit as one of Arya's mentors rather than Roose Bolton? That is one of few changes HBO made that I really, really appreciated (another being the Hound vs Brienne fight - that was just badass).
Three Tragedies you'll witness. One for Honor(Ned), One for Power(Red Wedding), One for... something else.
One for Life (ala Wight War)?
Three Masters you'll have. One for Water(Syro), One for.. something, and One for Death(Jaqen).
Three Fathers you'll know. One for Honor (Ned), One for Cunning(Tywin), One For Blood(The Hound).
Starky Approves. Though isn't it funny how well Tywin fit as one of Arya's mentors rather than Roose Bolton? That is one of few changes HBO made that I really, really appreciated (another being the Hound vs Brienne fight - that was just badass).
Three Tragedies you'll witness. One for Honor(Ned), One for Power(Red Wedding), One for... something else.
One for Life (ala Wight War)?
Three Masters you'll have. One for Water(Syro), One for.. something, and One for Death(Jaqen).
One for Fire (burned Hound) or maybe War?
Fun idea, either way.
I dont think the Hound can be both a master and a father in this. Ned is only mentioned twice because in life he was extremely influential on her. And witnessing his death was the first of many turning points for Arya. It was the beginning of her List. And as this post points out. A girl has honor. But a girl also witnessed her father's head get chopped off for the sake of honor.
If There was a fire master for Arya it would have been the leader of the Brother of Banners during her short stay with them. Or the read bitch herself. (sorry Munky) I do like the idea that the Wight War could be a tragedy she witnesses for Life.
Of course, Dany's Prophecy of three all ended with love. (Which, btw, I'm headcanoning that that third mount she rides for love is Nym, in order to either save Arya or because Arya forces her onto Nyms back to safe her... but ssssh. Spoilers for FF)
I dont think the Hound can be both a master and a father in this.
Ah, that was my bad - brainfart. Yes. He can only appear once.
Of course, Dany's Prophecy of three all ended with love. (Which, btw, I'm headcanoning that that third mount she rides for love is Nym, in order to either save Arya or because Arya forces her onto Nyms back to safe her... but ssssh. Spoilers for FF)
Such a beautiful spoiler that I will pretend I never saw
I dont think the Hound can be both a master and a father in this.
Ah, that was my bad - brainfart. Yes. He can only appear once.
Of course, Dany's Prophecy of three all ended with love. (Which, btw, I'm headcanoning that that third mount she rides for love is Nym, in order to either save Arya or because Arya forces her onto Nyms back to safe her... but ssssh. Spoilers for FF)
Such a beautiful spoiler that I will pretend I never saw
It's not an official FF spoiler. It's just a good possibly. I spend way to much time considering the different prophecies of ASOIAF so I have more head canons then I have use for yet.
I loved how are was from teh time i began to watch Game of Thrones. I must say i wasn'T with the Show from the beginning. Visited my friend on a Weekend and since RTL2 was doing this all 10 episodes of Season 2 on one Weekend i got into it.
The very fist Scene i watched from Season 2-. It wa sthe one in which Tywyn and Arya had the conversation. "what do the People of the North say about this Robb Stark?" and then came this great conversation where she lists many Things and he asks if she believes that he can't die. And this answer together with how steadily she Looks at hime, like "soon, very soon you will get it" and answers him "Anyone can be killed" That was simpyl fabulour in my opinion.
Three Fathers you'll know. One of Honour (Ned), One of Cunning (Tywin), One of Blood (The Hound). Three Tragedies you'll witness. One to Faith (Ned/Sansa), One to Family (Red Wedding), One to Life (long night). Three Masters you'll have. One for Iron (Syro), One for love (Dany), and One for Death (Jaqen)
Post by kentuckycat88 on Dec 11, 2018 17:12:16 GMT
I feel like Arya is the one who still has Stark honor, in terms of morals but tempers it with reality. She killed the Frey's to avenge her family, but the Frey's struck the first blow. Poisoning may not be 'honorable' to some people in the show, but Arya did what was necessary.
I can't imagine that the Starks ruled for so long as Kings and put down multiple rebellions by playing the honorable role the whole time (although it would have been good to kill the Boltons thousands of years ago). Of course, that could have been the reason for some of those rebellions (others seeing them as weak).
I think Arya is the one that knows what is right and will generally follow what Ned taught her, but is willing to set it aside when she needs to for the protection of her family (a moral Tywin?)
Welcome~ This forum is a place for all Dany x Arya shippers to meet up and discuss the world, the lore, and the wonderful characters who make this ship! Have fun, everyone!