Now isn't this a fun topic for debate amongst both the ASOIAF and GoT fandom?
Starky's Personal Opinion:
Even when I was a young and optimistic bastard, I wanted Jaime to be the one to kill Cersei. And, in truth, I still do. To me, that is the most satisfying way to end her story.
But even if you do not consider the possibilities of Arya taking Jaime's face to finish her off and provide a GRRM-esque twist on that prophecy, there is still one major issue to overcome.
This is the prophecy:
And when your tears have drowned you, the valonqar shall wrap his hands about your pale white throat and choke the life from you.
Now, color me crazy.. but I think it's pretty difficult for someone with only -one hand- to 'wrap his hands about' a pale white throat and choke the life from anyone.
Now isn't this a fun topic for debate amongst both the ASOIAF and GoT fandom?
Starky's Personal Opinion:
Even when I was a young and optimistic bastard, I wanted Jaime to be the one to kill Cersei. And, in truth, I still do. To me, that is the most satisfying way to end her story.
But even if you do not consider the possibilities of Arya taking Jaime's face to finish her off and provide a GRRM-esque twist on that prophecy, there is still one major issue to overcome.
This is the prophecy:
And when your tears have drowned you, the valonqar shall wrap his hands about your pale white throat and choke the life from you.
Now, color me crazy.. but I think it's pretty difficult for someone with only -one hand- to 'wrap his hands about' a pale white throat and choke the life from anyone.
Any thoughts?
Ah Starky, you always pose the most interesting questions regarding personal theories on aspects of canon lore and history.
Like you, the irony of Jamie being the one to off Cersei was not only delicious irony. But would have truely brought him full circle and would have been poetic.
The theory about Arya being the one to kill Cersei is based upon two things. Shes on her list, and the idea that High Valaryan has no gender pronouns. And Valonqar is gender nutural in the same way as the "Prince that is Promise" prophecy, and that it simply means Younger Sibling, rather then younger brother/male cousin. And while I'd love to see things, this poetic justice of Arya finally, finally getting justice for her Father after all these years, the one lost Stark to yet be avenged.....
I'm personally starting to lean towards Euron Greyjoy being the one to do it. Why? Because....
And when your tears have drowned you, the valonqar shall wrap his hands about your pale white throat and choke the life from you.
This could totally be a reference to the drowned god which is the god of the Iron Islands and the Greyjoys. Or just a metaphor for the fact that Cersei has been trying to drown her sorrows (tears) with wine for years now. (wine and the blood of her enemies) Euron is also a younger brother. Just no Cersei's. But then, Maggy the Frog never said it was Cersei's young brother, just a younger brother/sibling.
The theory about Arya being the one to kill Cersei is based upon two things. Shes on her list, and the idea that High Valaryan has no gender pronouns. And Valonqar is gender nutural in the same way as the "Prince that is Promise" prophecy, and that it simply means Younger Sibling, rather then younger brother/male cousin.
Exactly this. Now, I am going to go on record to say I do not believe Arya kills Cersei in the books. I really, truly do not. But in the HBO show? I almost think she has to - because if she doesn't, what was all of her training/her entire character arc for?
To kill a weak, lecherous old man and his heirs?
As bad as the Red Wedding was, you don't place 2+ years of valuable screentime and plot on avenging that event an endgame for anyone.
It's already pretty much a given that Farmboy Jon gets to be the 'hero of the day' and kill the Night King, so even if Arya kicks a lot of ass in the war against the wights there's no huge payoff there (unless Jon can only kill him with her assistance - which could happen, but it won't because D&D want to give him all of the great panning Leading Man shots). So, really, looking at the large scale narrative.. what is left for Arya to do, to make her story worthwhile?
I'm personally starting to lean towards Euron Greyjoy being the one to do it.
And you have a very valid point.
People make a huge mistake when writing Euron off. The reality is, if Euron wasn't completely integral to the endgame plot in some way, he wouldn't have even been written into the series (he'd suffer the same fate as 'Book Aegon'). For Dumb and Dumber to put in the effort to rope him in, even late in the game, there has to be -some purpose- he has that no other existing character could accomplish. And it will be more than just him jabbing his finger up Cersei's bum.
So this could also lead to another very interesting question - if Arya's endgame in GoT does NOT involve killing Cersei, what do you all think it could be?
While most leaks indicate Arya lives through to the end (which fits with GRRMs original outline), I've also had a sinking feeling right from the start, due to this scene:
..That look on Ned's face at the end just guts me every time. It's like he's slowly realizing he set something in motion that will end up being the death of his child.
((bonus points to everyone else who also noticed how Syrio specifically points out 'only one hand' is needed to master this art - hey, that's perfect for imitating someone who only has one hand!))
The theory about Arya being the one to kill Cersei is based upon two things. Shes on her list, and the idea that High Valaryan has no gender pronouns. And Valonqar is gender nutural in the same way as the "Prince that is Promise" prophecy, and that it simply means Younger Sibling, rather then younger brother/male cousin.
Exactly this. Now, I am going to go on record to say I do not believe Arya kills Cersei in the books. I really, truly do not. But in the HBO show? I almost think she has to - because if she doesn't, what was all of her training/her entire character arc for?
To kill a weak, lecherous old man and his heirs?
As bad as the Red Wedding was, you don't place 2+ years of valuable screentime and plot on avenging that event an endgame for anyone.
It's already pretty much a given that Farmboy Jon gets to be the 'hero of the day' and kill the Night King, so even if Arya kicks a lot of ass in the war against the wights there's no huge payoff there (unless Jon can only kill him with her assistance - which could happen, but it won't because D&D want to give him all of the great panning Leading Man shots). So, really, looking at the large scale narrative.. what is left for Arya to do, to make her story worthwhile?
I'm personally starting to lean towards Euron Greyjoy being the one to do it.
And you have a very valid point.
People make a huge mistake when writing Euron off. The reality is, if Euron wasn't completely integral to the endgame plot in some way, he wouldn't have even been written into the series (he'd suffer the same fate as 'Book Aegon'). For Dumb and Dumber to put in the effort to rope him in, even late in the game, there has to be -some purpose- he has that no other existing character could accomplish. And it will be more than just him jabbing his finger up Cersei's bum.
Sad but true when it comes to Arya's HBO storyline and character arc.
Although, truth be told, she wouldnt even need faceless man training at this point to kill Cersei. Up until she returned to Winterfell, the only people who knew she was alive were Gendry, Hotpie (But it had been what? 4/5 years since they had seen 'Arry'?) and The Hound and Brienne - and those two hadnt seen her in 2+ years either. Everyone believes her to be long dead. That chances are, even if she managed to make it out of King's Landing when her father was executed, she would have died in a ditch some where in the Riverlands because she was eleven fucking years old at the time.
Hotpie wasnt going to tell anyone that he knew the younger daughter of House Stark. Hell, chances are, there were some days Hotpie thought he dreamed her up, like a imaginary friend. - Gendry wasnt telling about the scrappy 'not a lady' he knew years before, not when he himself had his own secrets that could get him killed.
The Hound wasnt telling anyone. After all, when he was being honest with himself, the she-bitch was the closest thing he had ever had to a daughter, and of course he wasnt going to rat out her continued existence.
And Brienne? The only person Brienne might have told would have been Sansa. And that is only "I met your sister once. But couldnt convince her to come with me" And Brienne, though ever honest, wouldnt want to give her new Lady false hope in case Arya was now dead.
So the four people who knew she was still alive werent going to tell a soul. To everyone else, she was long dead. Arya could have walked right into the Red Keep, gotten a job as a maid or something, and slit Cersei's throat while the bitch was drunk on wine. And do it while wearing her own face. Because no one would recognize her as everyone thinks shes dead, and its been at least seven years and Arya grew up.
- - -
As for writing Euron off... I personally write him off because I dont want to deal with his brand of mother fucking bat shit insane. But as far as HBO canon goes, I'm not writing him off yet. Hes too bat shit insane to not have a greater role to play other then, as you said, sticking a finger up Cersei's bum, and taking pot shots at Jamie.
So this could also lead to another very interesting question - if Arya's endgame in GoT does NOT involve killing Cersei, what do you all think it could be?
While most leaks indicate Arya lives through to the end (which fits with GRRMs original outline), I've also had a sinking feeling right from the start, due to this scene:
..That look on Ned's face at the end just guts me every time. It's like he's slowly realizing he set something in motion that will end up being the death of his child.
((bonus points to everyone else who also noticed how Syrio specifically points out 'only one hand' is needed to master this art - hey, that's perfect for imitating someone who only has one hand!))
I dont know. There was this over lay of clashing steel swords there, as the proud smile slowly fell from his face that made me think that while, yes, he was realizing he has set his daughter on the path of a warrior. - But that is a realization I imagine he had with Rob and Jon, and would have had with Bran and Rickon as well. He was more having flash backs. Personally, I think they were flash backs to the Tower of Joy. After all, Arya is supposed to look like Lyanna, and Ser Auther Dayne could weild a sword with one hand, hell, he could duel weild. Which I bet is extreamly unheard of in Westeros to wield two full blades at one time
It could also be the realization, as he watched Arya rapidly improve in that scene, that Arya's path would be a difficult one, because clearly, the gods had fashioned her to be a swordswoman, and swordswoman did not have a place in Westeros society.
As for what her end game could be if she doesnt kill Cersei... arg. idk. I like the leaks hinted that she goes back east. Maybe she returns to the Faceless Men in the end. Her list has been completed, she has had her vengeance, given the names to the god of death and now, with the remains of her family safe, she is content to be No One, since she has no place in Westeros.
And when your tears have drowned you, the valonqar shall wrap his hands about your pale white throat and choke the life from you.
So I just rewatched the HBO scene and they skipped everything after gold crowns/shrouds, so clearly the nuances got thrown out with that particular flavor of bathwater.
But as for the probably never be written bits, Revan's (or Revan/Starky, I didn't copy/paste far enough back) probably right about the drowned god and the Ironborn surrounding King's Landing, but I feel like the emphasis on 'pale white throat' is a little bit specific for just plain old strangulation when 'seas go dry' plays out as Dothraki ghost grass.
When there's white walkers coming through from the North, unchecked aspects of what the hell is going on in the great white Eyerie towers and with Young Griff/Aegon taking Storm's End, an exodus to White Harbor might feasibly be Cersei's only means of escape after she finishes royally fucking things up in King's Landing.
Be the change you want to see in the world.
Because if that's the line that reeled in Starky, someone else could be out there too, waiting for the courage to step forward and share their thoughts and talents. We're really not as scary as you might think
And when your tears have drowned you, the valonqar shall wrap his hands about your pale white throat and choke the life from you.
So I just rewatched the HBO scene and they skipped everything after gold crowns/shrouds, so clearly the nuances got thrown out with that particular flavor of bathwater.
But as for the probably never be written bits, Revan's (or Revan/Starky, I didn't copy/paste far enough back) probably right about the drowned god and the Ironborn surrounding King's Landing, but I feel like the emphasis on 'pale white throat' is a little bit specific for just plain old strangulation when 'seas go dry' plays out as Dothraki ghost grass.
When there's white walkers coming through from the North, unchecked aspects of what the hell is going on in the great white Eyerie towers and with Young Griff/Aegon taking Storm's End, an exodus to White Harbor might feasibly be Cersei's only means of escape after she finishes royally fucking things up in King's Landing.
Except... Young Griff/Aegon isnt a thing in the HBO show.. sooooo
So I just rewatched the HBO scene and they skipped everything after gold crowns/shrouds, so clearly the nuances got thrown out with that particular flavor of bathwater.
But as for the probably never be written bits, Revan's (or Revan/Starky, I didn't copy/paste far enough back) probably right about the drowned god and the Ironborn surrounding King's Landing, but I feel like the emphasis on 'pale white throat' is a little bit specific for just plain old strangulation when 'seas go dry' plays out as Dothraki ghost grass.
When there's white walkers coming through from the North, unchecked aspects of what the hell is going on in the great white Eyerie towers and with Young Griff/Aegon taking Storm's End, an exodus to White Harbor might feasibly be Cersei's only means of escape after she finishes royally fucking things up in King's Landing.
Except... Young Griff/Aegon isnt a thing in the HBO show.. sooooo
but they skipped strangulation prophecies in the HBO show so....
Be the change you want to see in the world.
Because if that's the line that reeled in Starky, someone else could be out there too, waiting for the courage to step forward and share their thoughts and talents. We're really not as scary as you might think
but they skipped strangulation prophecies in the HBO show so....
Then Cersei's hatred for Tyrion is based on.... what...? That hes a dwarf?
Is that it? That seriously takes away like a critical part of their relationship. Cersei's hatred/fear of Tyrion based upon Maggy the Frog's prophecy
Exactly, they didnt even give us the word valonqar to work with.
Be the change you want to see in the world.
Because if that's the line that reeled in Starky, someone else could be out there too, waiting for the courage to step forward and share their thoughts and talents. We're really not as scary as you might think
Then Cersei's hatred for Tyrion is based on.... what...? That hes a dwarf?
Is that it? That seriously takes away like a critical part of their relationship. Cersei's hatred/fear of Tyrion based upon Maggy the Frog's prophecy
Exactly, they didnt even give us the word valonqar to work with.
Welp. Add this to the pile of awesome shit that HBO left out.
Here we are, making up amazing theories and headcanons and pulling apart bits of lore like fucking champs. And they just toss the interesting things into the trash pile.
Fuck, no wonder why the show only fans gobble up the dumpster fire like its fucking gold.
It remains to be seen whether the show actually excised the whole issue of the "valonqar," or whether it simply hasn't shown that part of Maggy's prophecy to the viewers yet. But at the very least, Cersei still has a young and beautiful queen to worry about — and this time, she probably shouldn't make the mistake of jumping to conclusions.
I mean, they could still add in another 30 seconds of as yet unrevealed Maggy the Frog prophecy for those slow folks in the back that need to be bludgeoned to death with foreshadowing.
Be the change you want to see in the world.
Because if that's the line that reeled in Starky, someone else could be out there too, waiting for the courage to step forward and share their thoughts and talents. We're really not as scary as you might think
Welcome~ This forum is a place for all Dany x Arya shippers to meet up and discuss the world, the lore, and the wonderful characters who make this ship! Have fun, everyone!